But the stuff that Plato is interested in (laws from the inner necessity of an organism) can't be derived independent of a cosmos of character and relation. By attempting to think of all of the Just City, or of the mind, independent of its formation or context, is simply impossible.
That's why I think the "noble lie" at the heart of the Platonic pedagogy (for guardians) is seriously flawed. Plato is covering his tracks because none of this philosophy of organism actually can deal with generation
https://youtu.be/XGGiNbtz-48
We passed the Rubicon last year. All that's left is for everyone else to notice it.
So to be perfectly plain about it, Peirce doesn't think that there's much access to experience outside of the processing of these 3 aspects of significance: the fundamental character or quality of something; its clash with the character of something else; and whatever upshot emerges from the mediation of these two. The last item can then become the fundamental character of something else, and you can construct very complex structures of experience by chaining quiddities together like this.
So as a fledgling Peircean, the problem with this is that there's nothing *to* a system of laws and necessity that exists in isolation of the world of mutability.
I was on a podcast where kids quizzed two people to decide who was a fake and who was a real expert.
The host said early on, the kids thought the fake was the expert every time because the actors answered every question confidently and the experts would hedge or even sometimes say, "I don't know."
They eventually told the fakes to be less confident so the kids would pick the expert sometimes.
It just occurred to me this is now real life with #chatGPT (but nobody is telling it to back off).
He said Candyman Rodriguez was one of his buddies:
https://www.kwtx.com/2022/05/17/7-years-ago-today-shootout-waco-twin-peaks-leaves-9-dead-18-wounded/
At a certain point when he was telling me about one of his near-death experiences, I got crazy déjà vu. It's probably just a blood sugar thing, though.
He currently lives in an RV and travels the US. He's got a wife who has stuck with him through all of this.
Humanist interested in the consequences of the machine on intellectual history.