the thing about opposition to ranking/grading is that its reducto ad absurdum is a world quite similar to that which hard collectivists desire; w/o a way to determine priority in a resource constrained world, everyone gets an equal split of a single much smaller pie

suboptimal
---
RT @nickcammarata
It’s messed up that we’re “graded” by authority figures every day starting from six years old. Kids that young aren’t capable of compart…
twitter.com/nickcammarata/stat

Follow

while material scarcity remains (& it still does, esp. considering logistical difficulties), it's simply delusional to imagine that its possible to operate a civilization w/o "unfair" distinctions based on the lottery of birth; some people are much more skilled than others

how do we decide who should be in charge of various critical functions w/o discrimination? would you be okay w/ your surgeon being picked from the population at random?

perhaps if we accept reality, rather than ignore it, we can work to improve on it

---
RT @chaosprime
so lovely, Nick's sunnily generous assumption that this impression is somehow mistaken rather than being an example of the children having a better idea of what's going…
twitter.com/chaosprime/status/

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Mastodon

a Schelling point for those who seek one