Okay, new plan if waiting around for it to dry doesn't work (and I'm not optimistic)
Heat it up enough in the microwave to be pourable, pour it into the saucepan again, heat it up till the boiling point is the correct temperature, pour it back into the thing it's in now
Okay I did that
Wondering if maybe my problem the second time was the thermometer reporting a lower temperature than it actually was because the bulb was only partially submerged?
That happened this time but luckily I double-checked it with my instant read thermometer